The "Carnal Christian"

Much is said today about the "carnal Christian." Such a one, we are told, has made Jesus "Savior" but not Lord. It appears by this that a man can be saved, but not surrendered to Christ; following Him, but still serving self. And it is easy to see why this idea has arisen. Preachers and personal workers are at a loss to explain the strange contradiction of a self-pleasing, self-centered person who claims the name "Christian" without bearing any resemblance to this Savior they profess to love. Yet ask them, "Do you believe in Christ? Have you accepted Him as your personal Savior?" "Oh, yes," is the invariable answer. If these are all the basics, they are apparently in order, so another source of counsel must be sought other than conversion.

Out of a morass of uncertain Christianity, men have looked for a way to distinguish between an "effective" Christian who lives like his Lord, and the "believer" who seems no different from his pagan neighbor. The distinction has been made between making Christ Savior and believing Him for salvation and making Him Lord that He might use this person for service. This "carnal Christian" becomes a middle stage person. He may partly serve God and at the same time partly serve himself. His ticket to heaven is guaranteed, his discipleship is optional. All this, we trust, can be substantiated by Holy Scripture. Can it?

Just what does God have to say about the "carnal man"? Before examining this question, you should understand that God looks at the heart of man. Whatever you are on the outside, God looks at your heart. He knows the real reason why you live the way you do. Because of the simple fact that almost every Christian duty and feeling can be imitated or duplicated by the unsaved man, we will concentrate on God’s analysis of conversion and God’s verdict on this issue. It will do no good to ask, "What are people who call themselves Christians, doing today?", and make these findings the criterion of true faith. Our guide must be the Bible, for on the evidence of this Holy Book, rests the final truth of each matter of faith.

Just how much like a Christian can a sinner be? The Bible answers, exceedingly so. It tells us that an unsaved man can be strictly moral in his outward life (Matt. 23:8); outwardly very prayerful (Mk. 12:40); zealous in religion (Matt. 23:15); and conscientious in doing what is expected of him. (Matt. 23:23) None of these things are necessarily the sign of a true child of God. An unsaved man may be very much like a Christian in desires; to be of some use to others, to make converts and give money for the work of religion (1 Cor. 13:3; Matt. 23:15; Lk. 18:12). But desires are not the measure of true faith. The sinner may hate the same things a Christian hates but for a totally different reason, and that difference brings him a totally different destiny. It is the heart, or the supreme, ultimate choice man lives for that determines whether he is a true Christians or not in God’s sight. If the heart is wrong, everything else is wrong, no matter what is done outwardly. Either your heart is set on serving Christ supremely or it is set on  serving yourself supremely. You are loving or you are selfish. You are living intelligently or unintelligently. You belong to God or you do not. (Matt. 6:22-24; 7:17-20; 12:33-35; Jn. 3:19-21; Rom. 6:16-18; 2 Cor. 5:17; Tit. 1:15; Jas. 3:10-11)

It’s Hard To Tell the Phony (Sometimes)

The sinner may want to glorify God, and still be unsaved! The true saint does this because he loves Him, and wants to see Him glorified; the counterfeit, because he believes this is the way to be saved, and desires it as a means to his great end, his own benefit. The counterfeit may want to repent, because he is afraid if he does not he will be lost; the Christian repents because he hates sin itself, because it dishonors God. They may both believe in Christ; the true saint because he loves Him; the other, that he might have a hope of Heaven.

They may both feel like obeying God; the Christian, that he might be more like his Lord; the counterfeit because he wants the rewards of obedience. Desires are the same; the heart, in each case, totally different. One is saved; the other is not.

They may also agree in actual affections and resolutions towards certain things. A counterfeit may even "love," (as far as feelings are concerned), such things as the Bible, prayer and witnessing, even "love" Christ and the Father - yet still be unsaved! Feelings are not the true test of faith. God sees the heart, and the essential difference is this; the true saint loves God with the unselfish love of trust and obedience, because he sees His character to be supremely excellent and lovely and he loves Him for His own sake. The counterfeit "loves" God with a feeling of "buddy-buddy" affection, because he thinks God is his particular friend that is going to make him happy forever, and why shouldn’t he love Him? (Matt. 5:46) The Christian loves Christ because he has responded to His love provision for us to return to God. (1 Jn. 4:19) The phony loves because he thinks God is going to save him from Hell and give him eternal life among other things, and he connects the friendship of Christ with his own selfish interests. The saint loves Him for what He is; the counterfeit, for what He gives. One seeks the Giver; the other, His gifts. One gives himself to God to do whatever He asks; the other comes to get whatever he can for himself, his own happiness and his own selfish purpose in life. (John 6:26-29; John 2:24)

Both true and false may feel badly about the low state of religion or church; both hate infidelity, injustice, and prejudice. The true saint, because it is opposed to God, to holy living, and to his Kings’ Kingdom. The counterfeit, because it injures an interest in which he is concerned, (for himself, of course), and if allowed to spread, will injure his hopes for happiness, oppose the religion he has chosen, and run contrary to his own views and opinions. (Matt. 5:20) A man can even "hate" sin and yet not forsake it, being no more a Christian than the devil. How often an addict hates drugs because they have ruined him, but not for sins’ sake. He hates their bad effects, but loves the sin itself. Both may attend religious meetings, pray in secret, be self-denying and even be willing to suffer martyrdom for their faith. Yet, even in these, the basic motive of each may be utterly opposed. One has truly changed his direction and supreme purpose of life from living for self, to living for God. His life is moved and marked by love, he unselfishly chooses the highest good of God and the universe to the best of his knowledge. The other has merely changed his means of serving himself, from the secular to the religious. His life is marked and motivated by selfishness. He wants his own happiness above the interests of everyone in the universe, including God.

Now, if the Bible be our guide, it is clear that a man cannot truly be called a Christian when he is supremely selfish. And if the "selfish Christian" cannot be found in the Bible, as far as God is concerned, there is no such thing. Yet it is said that the Bible teaches this, and such a person may be called a "carnal Christian". Let us first examine the Bible signs of the carnal man, to see whether or not we may call him at least a partial Christian.

The word "carnal" comes from the Greek root "sarx" (flesh) giving "sarkikos" meaning "fleshly." Each time the word "flesh" or "fleshly" is used in the Bible describing a moral action, it can be replaced by the word "carnal". The two words are the same in Greek, they only differ in some English translations. Let us first of all list the signs of the carnal man as opposed to the spiritual man in Romans chapter 8:

These are hardly encouraging Scriptures for the "carnal Christian" philosophy. However, Paul lists another set of signs characterizing the carnal man in Galatians 5:16-26

… "of the which I told you before, as I have also told you in times past that they which do such things shall not inherit the Kingdom of God." (v.21)

*NOTE especially these starred characteristics for later reference.

Another list of the characteristics of carnal people is given in 2 Peter 2:9-22. We are told that they are ungodly and are reserved for judgment (2:9). Those singled out for the worst judgment are those who have known the Gospel and still live selfishly and carnally. They "walk after the flesh" in the lust of uncleanness and despise government, (rule or authority; immediately, of a society, but ultimately of God, refusing His Lordship). (2:10)

They are self-willed and self-loving, (AMP 2:10) showing most of the signs of the people in Galatians 5:16-26: fornication (2:14), uncleanness (2:10), lasciviousness (2:2), emulations (2:18), sedition (2:10), heresies (2:1) drunkenness and revellings (2:13). These men are cursed (2:14), they have forsaken the right way, gone astray (2:15) slaves of sin (2:19). "…to whom the mist of darkness is reserved forever" This does not sound like heaven!

It should be reasonably evident now, that a man who claims to be a "carnal Christian" does not have a very promising future, because his life is identical with the unsaved man. He is a slave to the flesh, a servant of his own desires and as such a rebel against the good rule of God, righteousness, and holiness.

But it is asked, "Didn’t Paul address the Corinthian Christians as 'carnal' in I Cor. 3:l?" Since this is the only passage where the word "carnal" is used where a superficial reading might give the impression of a "selfish Christians" - notwithstanding the above Scriptures listed by Paul himself against this very idea, let us examine it in detail. If the "carnal" Christian philosophy is not taught here, it is not taught anywhere in the Bible. And if it is taught here, this passage is in direct contradiction to those already studied.

NOTE in introduction:

SETTING ANALYSIS: I Cor. 2:9-16

This sets the atmosphere for a searching, but loving rebuke. Paul has heard of some very suspicious activities still going on in this Corinth church. Sin could only occur if:

From this, Paul says: "I, brothers, could not speak to you as spiritual (men) but as carnal (natural, fleshly, unsaved men) as babies in Christ (or; as uninstructed people in the Word of God as to what a Christian should be like). He explains further by saying the first time he spoke to them, they had so little light they hardly seemed like Christians, so he had to give them "milk" (simple, basic facts of true faith for conversion). But, now some have still not changed! A "baby’’ Christian is not partially selfish and "growing" from partial repentance and commitment to complete repentance. All true men of God have forsaken all known sin, and are not knowingly living in sin. A Christian "grows" by responding to moral light given and disciplining new areas as God reveals.

If they were babies, they should have learned last time. There was only one other explanation for such sin problems continuing under the light of truth he had given them:

"For you are yet (still must be unsaved) carnal; for whereas there is among you:

"...are you not carnal, and walk as men?" or "Are you not worldly-minded and behave like the unconverted" (Berk.) (1 Cor. 3:3)

Notice carefully: Paul makes no case for a selfish Christian at all. There is no option here to forsake all sin; it is an absolute necessity. No honest Bible scholar could at all justify the salvation of a man who still lives in sin. If he does not know what he is doing is wrong, it is not sin. (Rom. 7:7-9; Jas. 4:17; Lk. 23:34; 12:47-48; 11:47-51; Jn. 9:41; 15:22,24) If he sins ignorantly, he is a baby; if he sins knowingly, he is a phony.

"Christian" implies being a "little-Christ" or "Christ-like". ( 1 Jn. 2:6;4: 17; 3:7,3) What kind of blasphemous combination is a "Carnal Christ-Like?" You might as well talk about "godly sinners" or "heavenly devils". God sees sinners. He sees saints. He does not see "sinful saints" or "saintly sinners". What fellowship has light with darkness? We are good or bad, selfish or loving. No definition of a Christian, that allows fellowship with the sin that cost God His Son and Christ His life, comes from the Holy Spirit of God. The "carnal Christian" philosophy is all right in its place. That place is Hell. If you are living in known sin, it is time you quit. If you live a carnal life, you are not a Christian, and have no right to call yourself one. "Carnal" or otherwise.

Neither does the following passage, (1 Cor. 3:5-15), refer to a "selfish" Christian who has not served God on earth, makes heaven, but loses his "rewards" in the fire. Paul is not talking about salvation, but ministries. This passage is a terrible warning to a man who tries to build a ministry on his own basic salvation, (through Christ the Foundation Stone), but presents a substandard message. He preaches to others a salvation God cannot justify or endorse. Through carelessness or spiritual blindness, tradition or man-centered activism, he fails to faithfully present God’s conditions for new birth. He himself is saved, but all his work and ministry of substandard quality and presentation is burned. (I Cor. 3: 15)

Ministers, personal-workers, teachers, will you be in that awful number? And you who claim you are a "carnal Christian", will you be lost in that terrifying fire? May God bring you to your knees, men and women of the Gospel, that you may reexamine your lives or ministries in the strong, clear light of the Holy Scriptures. If you have justified sin, will you now finish with it, forever? Will you cry out to God to strip away the filthy rags of your own self-righteousness, and come naked and humbled to the foot of the cross? Will you do it?

"No man can serve two masters; for either he will love the one and hate the other; or else he will hold to the one and despise the other..." "Choose ye this day whom you will serve!"

Part 3

PDF Version

Revision 1.1 ©1998 Winkie Pratney.
Contact at Box 876 Lindale TX 7577